Neco 2018 Christian Religious Studies Question 24

Practice objective / multiple choice question 24 from the 2018 Neco Christian Religious Studies examination.

Neco 2018 Christian Religious Studies Objective / Multiple Choice Hard Difficulty
Question 24 NECO • 2018 • CHRISTIAN_RELIGIOUS_STUDIES • objective

A Christian hospital must allocate one of two available kidneys. Patient A is a 45‑year‑old non‑addict with a projected 10‑year survival; Patient B is a 30‑year‑old recovering drug addict who has shown genuine repentance and has a projected 8‑year survival. Using the Christian ethical principles of sanctity of life, justice, and mercy, decide which patient should receive the kidney and justify your decision.

Answer Options

A. The kidney should be given to Patient B. Christian mercy, however, dictates that a person with a history of addiction should not be rewarded, so the organ should instead be offered to the non‑addict.
Correct Answer B. The kidney should be given to Patient B. While both lives are equally sacred, Christian mercy and the opportunity for redemption justify prioritising the younger, repentant addict despite the slightly shorter projected survival.
C. The kidney should be given to Patient A. Because both lives are equally sacred, the principle of beneficence requires allocating the organ to the patient with the greatest expected lifespan.
D. The kidney should be given to Patient A. Christian justice and the longer projected survival favor the older non‑addict, making him the more appropriate recipient.
Correct Answer
B
Correct Option:
The kidney should be given to Patient B. While both lives are equally sacred, Christian mercy and the opportunity for redemption justify prioritising the younger, repentant addict despite the slightly shorter projected survival.

About This Question

This is Neco 2018 Christian Religious Studies Question 24. It is one of the objective questions from the 2018 Neco Christian Religious Studies examination.

Difficulty level: Hard .

View More Neco 2018 Christian Religious Studies Questions More Neco Practice Questions Back to Questions

Master the Exam!

You've seen a preview, but there are thousands more questions plus AI tutor to break down complex solutions.

Unlock Full Access Available for Android & Windows
Chat with Support