In a school debate on the motion "School uniforms should be mandatory", the following two arguments are presented:

Argument 1 (Pro): "Uniforms eliminate the pressure to wear fashionable clothes, which reduces bullying and helps students focus on learning."
Argument 2 (Con): "If we force everyone to wear the same clothes, we are denying students the freedom to express themselves, which is a basic human right."

Identify which argument contains a logical fallacy, name the fallacy, and justify your identification.

Question

In a school debate on the motion "School uniforms should be mandatory", the following two arguments are presented:

Argument 1 (Pro): "Uniforms eliminate the pressure to wear fashionable clothes, which reduces bullying and helps students focus on learning."
Argument 2 (Con): "If we force everyone to wear the same clothes, we are denying students the freedom to express themselves, which is a basic human right."

Identify which argument contains a logical fallacy, name the fallacy, and justify your identification.

Accepted Answer

Argument 2 - it contains an appeal to emotion (appeal to freedom) fallacy.

Igcse Model Questions Vol1 2022 English Language Question 3

Answer Options

About This Question

Master the Exam!