Gce Model Questions Vol1 2024 Christian Religious Studies Question 23

Practice objective / multiple choice question 23 from the 2024 Gce Model Questions Vol1 Christian Religious Studies examination.

Gce Model Questions Vol1 2024 Christian Religious Studies Objective / Multiple Choice Hard Difficulty
Question 23 GCE_MODEL_QUESTIONS_VOL1 • 2024 • CHRISTIAN_RELIGIOUS_STUDIES • objective

A physician discovers that a patient has a highly contagious disease. The patient, fearing stigma, refuses to tell his family or authorities. The physician must decide whether to keep confidentiality or disclose the information. Using the Christian ethical principles of the Sanctity of Life, the commandment "Thou shalt not bear false witness", and the principle of agape (love), determine the ethically appropriate course of action and justify it by applying a hierarchy of moral principles.

Answer Options

A. The physician should report the disease anonymously to public health authorities without informing the family, because the principle of justice requires population protection while minimizing breach of confidentiality.
Correct Answer B. The physician should breach confidentiality and inform the family/authorities, because the higher Christian principle of love (agape) and the duty to protect life outweigh the duty of confidentiality; truthfulness also requires not misleading others about a real danger.
C. The physician should seek the patient's consent before any disclosure, because Christian ethics prioritize autonomy and the principle of non‑maleficence; only with consent can truthfulness be upheld.
D. The physician should maintain confidentiality and not disclose the information, because the Christian principle of respecting individual dignity and the commandment against false witness outweigh the duty to protect life; preserving trust is paramount.
Correct Answer
B
Correct Option:
The physician should breach confidentiality and inform the family/authorities, because the higher Christian principle of love (agape) and the duty to protect life outweigh the duty of confidentiality; truthfulness also requires not misleading others about a real danger.

About This Question

This is Gce Model Questions Vol1 2024 Christian Religious Studies Question 23. It is one of the objective questions from the 2024 Gce Model Questions Vol1 Christian Religious Studies examination.

Difficulty level: Hard .

View More Gce Model Questions Vol1 2024 Christian Religious Studies Questions More Gce Model Questions Vol1 Practice Questions Back to Questions

Master the Exam!

You've seen a preview, but there are thousands more questions plus AI tutor to break down complex solutions.

Unlock Full Access Available for Android & Windows
Chat with Support