Gce Model Questions Vol1 2018 Christian Religious Studies Question 43

Practice objective / multiple choice question 43 from the 2018 Gce Model Questions Vol1 Christian Religious Studies examination.

Gce Model Questions Vol1 2018 Christian Religious Studies Objective / Multiple Choice Hard Difficulty
Question 43 GCE_MODEL_QUESTIONS_VOL1 • 2018 • CHRISTIAN_RELIGIOUS_STUDIES • objective

A doctor must allocate a single available donor heart. The two possible recipients are: (a) a convicted murderer who has served ten years of a life sentence, and (b) a terminally ill five‑year‑old child with no chance of recovery without the transplant. Using Christian ethical principles, identify which principle should take precedence, decide which patient should receive the heart, and justify the decision in light of the teachings on the sanctity of life, the preferential option for the vulnerable, and the principle of love.

Answer Options

A. The principle of love should take precedence; consequently the heart should be given to the adult, as forgiving him aligns with Christian forgiveness.
Correct Answer B. The preferential option for the vulnerable should take precedence; consequently the heart should be given to the terminally ill child, because this respects the sanctity of life, embodies Christ‑like love, and prioritises the most defenseless over a convicted adult.
C. The principle of justice should take precedence; consequently the heart should be given to the convicted murderer, because all lives are equally valuable regardless of status.
D. The sanctity of life principle should take precedence; consequently the heart should be allocated to the adult, as he has already served his sentence and can contribute to society.
Correct Answer
B
Correct Option:
The preferential option for the vulnerable should take precedence; consequently the heart should be given to the terminally ill child, because this respects the sanctity of life, embodies Christ‑like love, and prioritises the most defenseless over a convicted adult.

About This Question

This is Gce Model Questions Vol1 2018 Christian Religious Studies Question 43. It is one of the objective questions from the 2018 Gce Model Questions Vol1 Christian Religious Studies examination.

Difficulty level: Hard .

View More Gce Model Questions Vol1 2018 Christian Religious Studies Questions More Gce Model Questions Vol1 Practice Questions Back to Questions

Master the Exam!

You've seen a preview, but there are thousands more questions plus AI tutor to break down complex solutions.

Unlock Full Access Available for Android & Windows
Chat with Support